The Atman-Brahman in Ancient Buddhism

The Atman-Brahman in Ancient Buddhism

ISBN: 9788120840652

Author: Kamleswar Bhattacharya

Subject: Buddhism

Language: English

Binding: Hard Back

Pages: 272

Publisher: Motilal Banarsidass

Availability: In Stock

Rating:    

No Review Yet.

INR 800.00

Info

About Book:

The thesis of this book is epoch-making. While no one doubts that the Buddha denied the atman, the self, the question is: Which atman? Buddhism, as understood in the modern era, has taken this to be the universal atman taught in the Hindu Upanisads, equivalent to brahman. What we find in the Buddha's words as recorded in the Buddhist scriptures, however, is only a denial of any permanent self in the ever-changing aggregates that form a person. In decades of teaching, the Buddha had many opportunities to clearly deny the impersonal universal atman if that was his intention. He did not do so.

The most serious objection to Kamaleswar Bhattacharya's thesis that the Buddha did not deny the universal atman may be put in the form of this question: Why, then, did Buddhists down through the ages think he did? Reply: Actually, they did not think this, as far as we can tell from their writings that refute the atman and teach the anatman or no-self doctrine. The idea of the atman as the impersonal universal atman did not become dominant in India until some time after the eighth century C.E. Before then, throughout the Buddhist period, the dominant idea of the atman in India was that of a permanent personal atman. Judging from their writings, the Indian Buddhist teachers from Nagarjuna to Aryadeva to Asanga to Vasubandhu to Bhavya to Candrakirti to Dharmakirti to Santaraksita thought that the Buddha's anatman teaching was directed against a permanent personal atman.

About Author:

REVIEWS

SIMILAR PRODUCTS

  • Bodhisattvas of the Forest and the Formation of the Mahayana

    Buddhism
    Daniel Boucher

    INR 595.00

    Shop Now
    Bodhisattvas of the Forest and the Formation of the Mahayana
  • Indo-Tibetan Studies [Buddhica Britannica Vol. 2]

    Buddhism
    Tadeusz Skorupski

    INR 1800.00INR 2000.00

    Shop Now
    Indo-Tibetan Studies [Buddhica Britannica Vol. 2]
  • The Cult of The Deity Vajrakila [Buddhica Britannica Vol. 4]

    Buddhism
    Martin J. Boord

    INR 1800.00INR 2000.00

    Shop Now
    The Cult of The Deity Vajrakila [Buddhica Britannica Vol. 4]
  • The Far Shore

    Buddhism
    Mitchell Ginsberg

    INR 275.00

    Shop Now
    The Far Shore
  • Dharmakirti's Theory of Hetu-Centricity of Anumana

    Buddhism
    Mangala R. Chinchore

    INR 750.00

    Shop Now
    Dharmakirti's Theory of Hetu-Centricity of Anumana
  • Studies in the Lankavatara Sutra

    Buddhism
    D. T. Suzuki

    INR 895.00

    Shop Now
    Studies in the Lankavatara Sutra
  • The Debate of King Milinda

    Buddhism
    Bhikkhu Pesala

    INR 595.00

    Shop Now
    The Debate of King Milinda
  • The Tibetan Book of the Great Liberation

    Buddhism
    W.Y. Evans-Wentz

    INR 295.00

    Shop Now
    The Tibetan Book of the Great Liberation
  • Bauddh Dharma-Darshan

    Buddhism
    Narendra Dev

    INR 895.50INR 995.00

    Shop Now
    Bauddh Dharma-Darshan
  • The Three Boys

    Buddhism
    Yeshi Dorjee, John S. Major

    INR 225.00

    Shop Now
    The Three Boys